The conversation about a potential pullback in the U.S. stock market has gained significant traction as analysts dive into data and trends that signal shifts in market dynamicsAlthough the S&P 500 index is currently hovering about 5% below its record high set on December 6, 2022, many market experts suggest that this apparent resilience may mask deeper vulnerabilities.

Historical patterns indicate that as the market celebrates successive years of growth, caution should be exercisedAccording to Bank of America’s technical strategist Stephen Suttmeier, the S&P 500 may become a victim of its own successHe notes that after robust growth in 2023 and 2024, 2025 is projected to carry increased risks, hinting at potential volatility that has many investors on edge.

Suttmeier highlights that in the third year of recent bull markets, the average return for the S&P 500 has been a modest 5%, a stark contrast to the historical average annual returns of around 10%. These statistics underscore concerns that the current market's rally may be overextended.

Amidst the seemingly stable average indices, a look beneath the surface reveals troubling signs of deteriorationDespite the top-line indicators showing only minor declines, internal metrics suggest broader challengesLPL Financial's chief technical strategist Adares Turnquist pointed out the recent emergence of technical flaws, warning that as we transition into 2025, momentum within the equities market appears to be stalling, with broadening deterioration signaling potential for deeper corrections.

Out of the 11 sectors in the stock market, only six are currently trading above their 200-day moving averages, a significant drop from the end of December 2022 when all sectors were above this lineThis change reflects a weakening overall upward momentum, hinting that adjustments are underway in certain sectorsMoreover, the proportion of S&P 500 constituents above the 200-day moving average has dropped sharply from roughly 76% to 55% over the past month, according to StockCharts data.

The 200-day moving average carries substantial significance as a technical indicator, aiding traders in defining the long-term direction of a trend

Advertisements

When securities slip below this threshold, it generates a warning signal of a potential shift from an upward trajectory to a downward one, prompting active trader scrutiny.

With rising anxiety surrounding an impending sell-off in the U.S. stock market, several notable strategists have weighed in on the possible pain investors might faceFirst, Will Tapping, a senior analyst at Fairlead Strategies, suggests that the rising 200-day moving average serves as a rational support level to watchCurrently, this technical level hovers around 5570 points; should the S&P 500 test this level and decisively drop below, the next support zone would be around 5337 points, correlating to a Fibonacci retracement of 38.2%. Such a move could result in a 10% decline from present levels, culminating in an approximate drop of 13% from peak to trough.

Next, Baird’s strategist Ross Mayfield shared a more bullish outlook regarding 2025 for the stock marketHowever, he also acknowledges the unmistakable potential for an upcoming adjustment, arguing it is overdue following two years of strong advancements in equity valuesHe neatly summarizes the stock market's corrective history: “We typically see a pullback every two years, but bear markets seldom occur without recession.” Mayfield expects a sustained economic expansion into 2025, leading to annual gains in the stock market; nevertheless, he anticipates a double-digit retreat akin to the early 2018 scenario, which aligns with historical averages amid expanding valuations and adverse market factors.

Finally, Sam Stovall of CFRA Research expressed his concern, stating, “We started this year off on the wrong foot.” He pointed out that the absence of a traditional Santa Claus rally during the final days of the old year and the initial days of the new year serves as a historically bearish indicator for the rest of the yearAn age-old Wall Street adage encapsulates this sentiment: “If Santa Claus doesn’t visit, the bear might be on its way to Wall Street.” Stovall pinpointed 5130 points from the Fibonacci analysis established at the start of this bull market in October 2022 as a critical support level for investors

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements